The appeal Inspector accepted that the appeal site, located on the edge of a large village, was a logical infill development surrounded by existing housing. The Inspector also agreed with Salmon Planning’s case that the development represented a sustainable and well-integrated extension of the village, with ready access to local services.
Heritage Considerations
A key issue in the appeal was the setting of a nearby Grade II listed building. The Inspector concluded that while there would be some limited harm to the heritage asset’s setting, this was outweighed by the significant public benefits of delivering much-needed housing - particularly in the form of affordable homes - in an area facing a severe housing land supply shortfall. Somerset Council (Area South) is only currently able to demonstrate 2.11 years’ supply.
Nutrient neutrality - phosphates
On environmental matters, the Inspector accepted that the bespoke phosphate mitigation strategy - comprising off-site woodland creation - would successfully achieve nutrient neutrality, enabling the scheme to proceed without harm to the integrity of the Somerset Levels and Moors Ramsar site.
A particularly noteworthy aspect of the Inspector’s decision was the conclusion that off-site phosphate mitigation could be secured via a planning condition rather than necessitating a Section 106 legal agreement. While the Council and the Appellant had disagreed on this point, the Inspector accepted that the Appellant held a suitable interest in the mitigation land and, referencing the advice of Natural England, saw no robust barrier to the strategy’s delivery.
We are proud to have helped our client achieve this important consent, unlocking the delivery of high-quality homes in a sustainable Somerset village. With the appeal now allowed, we look forward to the next phase of this excellent new development.